I believe there has been a lot of good stuff written about Tampa Bay Saltwater. I've never used them though. Should be a quick shipment for you since it is a short distance away. It might keep the die-off minimal in transit.
With sea-life, talk to ken (the owner) he is very very helpful. He knows a lot and you can talk to him about shipping over to your house with standard ground (since your so close). He can also give you the total price for it all. I also here he ALWAYS throws in something free with his shipment.