Planaria or Rhabdocoela

Cutty

New Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2020
Messages
15
Reaction score
4
Location
Sydney
Can anyone please help with identifying whether these are planaria or Rhabdocoela

Thanks
 

Attachments

  • 21F1C140-CB44-4798-B268-534C50C55594.jpeg
    21F1C140-CB44-4798-B268-534C50C55594.jpeg
    277.3 KB · Views: 116
  • 39E68EDC-39DD-4BDC-9DE6-6BE68C2B2659.jpeg
    39E68EDC-39DD-4BDC-9DE6-6BE68C2B2659.jpeg
    276.7 KB · Views: 101
  • 8E92FEDE-279F-4C49-BA5C-2E634D74ED96.jpeg
    8E92FEDE-279F-4C49-BA5C-2E634D74ED96.jpeg
    308.2 KB · Views: 115
  • E2502420-25A3-4BAD-B6ED-8AC14349AB00.jpeg
    E2502420-25A3-4BAD-B6ED-8AC14349AB00.jpeg
    259.4 KB · Views: 94
  • 128EC707-55EF-40B7-9067-C0CBDD44BDBD.jpeg
    128EC707-55EF-40B7-9067-C0CBDD44BDBD.jpeg
    284.8 KB · Views: 100
  • 071F8CEC-1B46-4B7F-9DEA-E403143A9479.jpeg
    071F8CEC-1B46-4B7F-9DEA-E403143A9479.jpeg
    228.2 KB · Views: 103
  • 1B5BB96E-695D-434B-9485-8706618565E3.jpeg
    1B5BB96E-695D-434B-9485-8706618565E3.jpeg
    268.9 KB · Views: 106
They don't look quite right for planaria because they don't have the 'crossed eyes'. Is the pointy end the bottom or front? If it's the trailing end I'd fairly confidently say they are not planaria.
 
I can’t see the eyes either.

They definitely have a pointed head, but not really the characteristic arrow head.

I don’t know what to do..
 
If you're really worried then start with a large water change and really thorough gravel vac. It can't do any harm as long as your tap water doesn't differ much from your tank water (for pH etc. for your fish). After that there are chemicals I believe, but I'm still not convinced they're planaria. Can you look at one down a microscope / with a magnifier? That would clinch it.
 
Thanks for the reply. Yeah, I think I will need a magnifying glass - as I am sure all the pics online are magnified. Especially when you see the very arrow like head and eyes.
 
More pics
 

Attachments

  • 49BE7BFA-5B6E-47CA-9CD6-3D65D7D1F590.jpeg
    49BE7BFA-5B6E-47CA-9CD6-3D65D7D1F590.jpeg
    125.9 KB · Views: 91
  • DA5B2BEB-711D-49AC-A54B-4BBF62995B2E.jpeg
    DA5B2BEB-711D-49AC-A54B-4BBF62995B2E.jpeg
    122.3 KB · Views: 92
  • FCBCAE1F-5911-4772-B8BB-B2B620448BD2.jpeg
    FCBCAE1F-5911-4772-B8BB-B2B620448BD2.jpeg
    90 KB · Views: 76
  • F283AD77-31A4-4E6B-8A6C-4C3EFE1B8480.jpeg
    F283AD77-31A4-4E6B-8A6C-4C3EFE1B8480.jpeg
    121.5 KB · Views: 85
  • 5FEA9653-5487-404A-B84A-F554957F2E1C.jpeg
    5FEA9653-5487-404A-B84A-F554957F2E1C.jpeg
    87.7 KB · Views: 75
  • 006368E7-03D8-4413-AE4D-CDE9EE93E9BD.jpeg
    006368E7-03D8-4413-AE4D-CDE9EE93E9BD.jpeg
    115 KB · Views: 89
  • 7A301781-846F-4345-BED5-D538EAFC8054.jpeg
    7A301781-846F-4345-BED5-D538EAFC8054.jpeg
    127.8 KB · Views: 83
1626167873626.png
I think one or two of those photos, like that last one, may resemble this enough to assume they are planarian worms. @Colin_T said to me they are only a threat to fish eggs. I thought they were a bigger risk than that, but only based on things I'd read on the net. If you're really worried I know there are chemicals to rid them but have no experience in them I'm afraid. Also the Siamese Flying Fox is meant to eat them, if you were looking for another fish.
 
Thanks for that. It does look very similar.
It’s funny how some pics show a very arrow like head and prominent eyes, and others, like above do not.
I have shrimp in the tank that is why I am worried, as they eat small shrimp.
 
I'd only seen the very arrow like pics too which is why I thought I'd scout around for comparisons with your new photos. That last one looks like it has 2 darkened areas where the 'eyes' go so, if the lighter spots just weren't clear enough due to resolution issues, I thought it might be a planarian. It's still not definite. Slippery little sods, aren't they!
 
No, the eyes aren’t clear at all to the plain eye - maybe under a microscope it’s different.

Thanks for all the effort.

It’s so hard to tell the difference between planaria and Rhabdocoela.

I think so far it’s 60% planaria and 40% not.
 
Final post with some better pics. Hopefully it clarifies what they are
 

Attachments

  • 3DB8AD2E-0F74-43F6-9FF2-D1C025BBD81F.jpeg
    3DB8AD2E-0F74-43F6-9FF2-D1C025BBD81F.jpeg
    138 KB · Views: 92
  • FDE59D67-B8C7-43BC-958C-54A399260032.jpeg
    FDE59D67-B8C7-43BC-958C-54A399260032.jpeg
    134.8 KB · Views: 93
  • 3C31BE60-4C02-4EB8-BCF2-1633D20DDD1F.jpeg
    3C31BE60-4C02-4EB8-BCF2-1633D20DDD1F.jpeg
    140.6 KB · Views: 89
  • 134BB7F5-8F98-4FD7-BB98-FC272F7D3622.jpeg
    134BB7F5-8F98-4FD7-BB98-FC272F7D3622.jpeg
    133.4 KB · Views: 91
  • B888F745-34FC-4F88-BE09-02270B179F7E.jpeg
    B888F745-34FC-4F88-BE09-02270B179F7E.jpeg
    142.2 KB · Views: 97
  • 4F3652B9-A13C-4F19-A05D-96FDFF9AB5C7.jpeg
    4F3652B9-A13C-4F19-A05D-96FDFF9AB5C7.jpeg
    131.8 KB · Views: 84
  • CA50B5C0-338F-49EE-A322-D038B2CEFEF9.jpeg
    CA50B5C0-338F-49EE-A322-D038B2CEFEF9.jpeg
    135.9 KB · Views: 100
  • 8BC82DDD-383D-4040-A5FF-B950B336C5A7.jpeg
    8BC82DDD-383D-4040-A5FF-B950B336C5A7.jpeg
    148.5 KB · Views: 102
Final post with some better pics. Hopefully it clarifies what they are
They have the eyes! Brilliant pics, by the way. So, definitely planaria. I'd give the tank and substrate a good wipe and vacuum if I were you and then consider treating it once you've removed any snails you want to keep, and probably the shrimp too.

I reckon you got there in the end identifying them!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top