Need To Identify This Fish

I recently bought a fish from a very large aquatic store I might add, and they literally had no clue what this fish was. It was with the kribensis tank. This was the only one and they gave it to me practically for free, $5. They said it was because they didn't know. Anyways I also want to say I recently found some fry, but only 3 and I think they're hybrids (from this fish and a blue cichlid I've had for awhile) The fry literally look like none of the supposed parents, but little color has shown. The pictures are of the same fish.

Definitely looks like a cichlid, but other than that I have no idea. Sorry.

Thank you for trying. I also don't know if it's old world or not.

Gotta say this was quite hard to find for me, not even sure if i've found the correct one since i know precious little about cichlid species
 
Think have whittled your specie down to being of Psudotropheus group
 
http/www.cichlid-forum.com/profiles/species.php?id=889
 
or 
 
http/www.africancichlids.net/gallery/gallery-malawi.php
(scroll down to Psudotropheus flavus and click on these 3 pictures)
 
Does these look anything like your fish in that tank?
 
Would suggest if its not that particular one, google search Psudotropheus species of cichlids and you may come across the one that most resembles your cichlid.
 
Do bear in mind though that there are over 1,400 specie of cichlid, so kind of a needle in haystack kinda search for someone like me
 
Good luck  

I have to say thanks again, but I actually do have psudotropheus species in the tank with him, that's the other blue fish. I will try and take some better pictures. The mystery fish is quite small and more round. In the pictures it looks more long and oval, I guess.

ok.

Here are some more pictures, I don't think they'll do any better, but she has a blue mouth, red fin, and orange body. My Pleco is roughly 14 in long, so you can see somewhat of a size. The blue fish is the other one. Much bigger than mystery fish. I've looked at a lot more fish online and I find things close, but never exact. I've had the mystery fish for almost 3 months. If I am able, should I make another thread in new world?